The initial issue that triggered this rework is that the forced storage in
database was working only on writes, and was never applied on attachment
creations.
This feature is used to store small files that need to be read in a fast way in
database rather than in the object storage. Reading a file from the object
storage can take 150-200ms, which is fine for downloading a PDF file or a single
image, but not if you need 40 thumbnails.
Down the path to make a correction, I found that:
* the logic to force storage was called in `_inverse_datas`, which is not called
during a create
* odoo implemented a new method `_get_datas_related_values`, which is a model
method that receive only the data and the mimetype, and return the attachment
values and write the file to the correct place
The `_get_datas_related_values` is where we want to plug this special storage,
as it is called for create and write, and already handle the values and
conditional write. But using this method, we have less information than before
about the attachment, so let's review the different criterias we had before:
* res_model: we were using it to always store attachments related to
'ir.ui.view' in db, because assets are related to this model. However, we
don't really need to check this: we should store any javascript and css
documents in database.
* exclude res_model: we could have an exclusion list, to tell that for instance,
for mail.message, we should never store any image in db. We don't have this
information anymore, but I think it was never used and added "in case of".
Because the default configuration is "mail.mail" and "mail.message" and I
couldn't find any attachment with such res_model in any of our biggest
databases. So this is removed.
* mimetype and data (size) are the last criteria and we still have them
The new system is only based on mimetype and data size and I think it's actually
more versatile. Previously, we could set a global size and include mimetypes,
but we couldn't say "I want to store all images below 50KB and all files of type
X below 10KB". Now, we have a single system parameter with a dict configuration
(`ir_attachment.storage.force.database`) defaulting to:
{"image/": 51200, "application/javascript": 0, "text/css": 0}
Assets have a limit of zero, which means they will all be stored in the database
whatever their size is.
Overall, this is a great simplification of the module too, as the method
`_get_datas_related_values` integrates it better in the base calls of IrAttachment.
Note for upgrade:
I doubt we customized the previous system parameters which are now obsolete, but
if yes, the configuration may need to be moved to `ir_attachment.storage.force.database`.
For the record, the params were:
* mimetypes.list.storedb (default: image)
* file.maxsize.storedb (default: 51200)
* excluded.models.storedb (mail.message,mail.mail), no equivalent now
The method IrAttachment.force_storage_to_db_for_special_fields() should be called
through a migration script on existing databases to move the attachments back into
the database.
Some attachments (e.g. image_small, image_medium) are stored in DB
instead of the object storage for faster access.
In some situations, we may have pushed all these files on the Object
Storage (migration from a filesystem to object storage) and want to
bring back these attachments from the object storage to the database.
This method is not called anywhere but can be called by RPC or scripts.
Assume the following situation:
* We have installed addons base, sale and attachment_s3 (hence
base_attachment_object_storage as dependency)
* All attachments are in S3 already
* We run an upgrade of the 'base' addon, 'sale' is upgraded before
attachment_s3 in the order of loading.
* Sale updates the icon of the Sale menu
* As attachment_s3 is not loaded yet, the attachment is created in the
filestore
Now if we don't persist the filestore or use different servers, we'll
lose the images of the menus (or any attachment loaded by the
install/upgrade of an addon).
The implemented solution is to move the attachments from the filestore
to the object storage at the loading of the module. However, this
operation can take time and it shouldn't be run by 2 processes at the
same time, so we want to detect if the module is loaded during a normal odoo
startup or when some addons have been upgraded. There is nothing anymore
at this point which allow us to know that modules just have been
upgraded except... in the caller frame (load_modules). We have to rely
on the inpect module and get the caller frame, which is not recommended,
but seems the only way, besides, it's not called often and if
_register_hook was called from another place, it would have no effect
(unless the other place has a variable 'update_module' too).
When moving attachments from the filestore to an object storage, the
filesystem files will be deleted only after the commit, so if the
transaction is rollbacked, we still have the local files for another
try.
Yannick Payot
Vincent RenavilleandGitHub
Stephane ManginandMaksym Yankin
Denis Leemann
Don Kendall
Patrick Tombez
Guewen Baconnier
Akim Juillerat
Tonow-c2c
jcoux
Thierry DucrestandGuewen Baconnier